Sunday, January 06, 2008

A Couple Of Humorous Bill O'Reilly Stories

First, a schoolgirl makes him look dumb - admittedly not the most arduous of tasks - and he refuses to admit his error.
During the course of plugging his new book, Kids Are American Too, on his show the other night (it "turned out to be a very hot Christmas gift this season!"), Bill O'Reilly thought it might be fun to answer questions from kids. But he was not prepared for Courtney Yong, from San Francisco. "Mr. O'Reilly, I really enjoyed Kids Are Americans Too," Courtney's question began, auspiciously enough. "But in the first sentence of Chapter Three you say the Constitution guarantees 'life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.' Isn't that from the Declaration of Independence?"

Now, some of us, in O'Reilly's situation, might have laughed. We might have made a joke about how everyone confuses those two old things, and later made a hissing, angry phone call to whatever HarperCollins editor let the sentence, "For openers, the Constitution guarantees all of us, in a famous phrase, 'life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness,'" slip by untweaked, since while, as the folks at Media Matters have noted, the Constitution promises the government shall not deprive any person "of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law," Courtney is right: "Pursuit of happiness" belongs to the Declaration.

But what did noted America lover Bill do? He tried to cover it up. No, worse — hilariously worse — he tried to act like he did it on purpose. "An excellent question, Courtney," he responded. "The reason the Constitution was forged was to assure new American citizens the right to free life and access to pursue happiness in his or her own way. The Declaration was the statement; the Constitution, the instrument."

Then, he starts a shoving match at an Obama rally.
With his camera crew behind him and the sound boom overhead, O'Reilly waited to grab the senator on his way out the door. I had been watching him since his arrival (his group had bumped into me at one of the two press platforms), and I followed him to watch the spectacle it was certain he would create.

At first, the railing where O'Reilly stood wasn't very populated. Then, as the Obama team saw who was laying in wait, they started to huddle. Staffers started to arrive at the scene. Three policemen showed up, too. One of them stood in front of O'Reilly until O'Reilly asked him to move. One of Obama's staffers, Marvin Nicholson, took up the same post, standing in front of the Fox camera as Obama neared the door.

"You're blocking our shot," yelled O'Reilly.

"Oh, am I?" asked the Obama staffer, not entirely sincerely, and not moving.

This is not a new trick. When staffers block you because you're being too aggressive, the standard thing to do is give them a little business and then move to another spot. O'Reilly didn't do this. He shoved the Obama aide. There was an exchange and a little more shoving. I didn't fully capture it because as I looked at O'Reilly in his black leather Fox jacket, which resembled the kind we wore during football season in high school, I swore I could hear him challenge the staffer to a rumble out by the drive-in.

"That's really low class, pal," said O'Reilly.

I love Bill O'Reilly. He makes living so much more fun.

Quote Of The Day

Our beloved President, on BB's assassination:
For standing up outside the car, I think it was she to blame alone. Nobody else. Responsibility is hers.

Guess they don't really teach sensitivity at St. Pat's. I mean, even if what he's saying is technically true, does he really need to be saying it?

Friday, January 04, 2008

Quote of the Day

Having seen a picture of Bilawal Bhutto dressed up as the Devil for a costume party (shown here), the 24 year old Maulana Mohavya Irshad of the Lal Masjid had this to say:

"Bilawal has become the target for those who killed Benazir Bhutto. His party (PPP) has to take extra care of him and look after his security"

"At this time, I don't know much about Bilawal. I only know he is a liberal person and that is deviation from Islam. True Muslims will not allow him to go against Islam,"

"These true Muslims will be horrified to see this image of Bilawal dressed as the devil with a pretty girl in his arm at a decadent party at Oxford University"

Right. So actually being a true manifestation of evil isn't a crime punishable by death, but dressing up as one is. I should add that in previous interviews Mr Irshad has stated his willingness to suicide bomb things in the name of what he thinks is Islam.

I should also add that Mr Irshad is of the opinion that the girl is cute.

Some Mindless Entertainment

It's been pretty heavy here at Rs. 5 for a few days, so here's some temporary relief.


Thursday, January 03, 2008

Can Benazir's Foreign Friends Please Stop Masquerading As Journalists?

So a friend of mine, who is intimately aware of Pakistani politics, commented on a post yesterday, saying among other things, "I don't recognize this person [BB] being spoken about in/by the media here [the U.S] *at all*." And it's true. While I'm all for being respectful of someone who recently died, and am completely fine with less than critical assessments of leaders immediately after they die, I think there's a fine line between being respectful and being a revisionist historian. This syndrome, which we can call BWATAM (Benazir Was All That And More), is especially likely to take hold if you (a) went to Harvard with BB and were charmed by her, (b) went to Oxford with BB and were charmed by her, (c) were in the British or American governments and/or legislatures between 1985 and 1995 and were charmed by her, or (d) were in Washington over the last 12 to 18 months and were charmed by her (or her $500,000-a-year lobbyists, same difference).

Look, I'm not trying to be asshole, I'm really not. As I've said before, her death is a tragedy for our country. But it's becoming increasingly difficult to read articles which use her nickname ("Pinky"), and talk about time spent in Bruges, and drinks at the Pierre, without a single reference to her political career. Or articles that take at face value Asif Zardari's assertion that he wasn't returning to Pakistan with BB because "the children ought to have at least one parent at home." Some of you might say: if you have a problem with said articles, don't read 'em. To that, I would retort: it's not my displeasure at the articles themselves per se - people can write whatever they hell they want, after all - but at the fact that the people writing them are writing them as journalists, in respected publications like Newsweek and Slate. They should have some sort of duty to objectivity.

I should emphasize that I have no problem with Westerners thinking the world of her. Why wouldn't they? She was charismatic, eloquent, and intelligent. Moreover, they didn't have to live in the Pakistan during the 1990s, so they never saw the other side of the ledger for themselves. Which, I reiterate, is fine: I'm sure there are millions of people out there of whom I have an incomplete picture but don't yet know it. But journalists/historians/political scientists/others of the same ilk should, in their obituaries and tributes, at least make a passing mention of the following:

1. The rampant corruption of her and her husband - known as Mr. 10% during her second term for the kickbacks he received on almost all government contracts (he was known as Mr. 5% in her first term). The necklaces, the Surrey estates, the apartments in Dubai and the Upper East Side of New York, and godknowswhatelse.
2. The widespread failure of her economic policies in the 1990s.
3. Her authoritarian, undemocratic, and unforgiving nature. Exhibit A is how she simply handed over the PPP - the nation's biggest and only truly national party - to a nineteen year old who doesn't have a college education, can't speak Urdu (let alone Sindhi), and is in way over his head. Exhibit B is how she sidelined and marginalized one of the most talented and brilliant politicians/lawyers in Pakistan, Aitzaz Ahsan, because he dared tread a different path from her vis-a-vis the Chief Justice and Musharraf. Both A and B, by the way, are drawn from the last two months alone. The further you go back in history, the more you'll find.

Again, I'm not trying to be asshole. But you can't be a journalist or political commentator of repute by pretending these traits didn't exist. If you want to grieve for her and Pakistan, that's great: we welcome your sympathy. But don't make her out to be someone she wasn't.

UPDATE: One thing you can't criticize her for is Pakistan's support for the Taliban and our Kashmir policy in the 1990s. Critics of BB point to her time in government and how these two largely unenlightened, unmoderate, and unsuccessful policies either began or were given continued support during those years. To those people, I say: the Army and the ISI controlled our foreign policy, at least insofar as our neighbors were concerned. There is nothing BB could have done. This is a matter of historical fact, not mere opinion.

ANOTHER UPDATE: Here's William Dalrymple in the NYT on a number of the issues raised in this post and in the comments in response to it.

On Krugman, Obama, and Partisan Politics

So Paul Krugman has gotten his panties in a twist over the last few weeks regarding Barack Obama's message of reconciliation and unity. He started by attacking Obama's health care plan ("he uses right-wing talking points!"), called Obama "naive", and then penned a three-page article in Slate saying the only way forward for progressives is to attack and snarl at Republicans and conservatives because their (progressives') moment is now.

While there is something to be said for a nationally renowned columnist and world-famous economist actually calling for more divisive and partisan politics, I will instead focus on another issue. Namely, uh, Barack Obama is black. Instead of me explaining this, I'll let a "black bourgeoisie" blog do so:
It has been disheartening to read 'Progressive' after 'Progressive' deride Barack Obama because they don't believe he'll be an attack dog like Hillary Clinton or Edwards. I don't know why it took me so long to vocalize this, but it came to me:

Barack Obama and no other Black candidate would EVER

and I mean EVER

campaign on a theme of 'attack dog', or anything remotely dealing with 'attacking' the opposition.

THEY WON'T GET ELECTED.

This doesn't mean that they roll over and play dead with the opposition. They will debate on the issues. They will be strong against their opponent. Being forceful without seeming nasty. They could never be the nasty, vengeful attack dog that Progressives seem to want. There is NO Black candidate that can to into an election with the strategy of "50%+1". It might TURN OUT that way, but there is no way that they can go into an election with that kind of strategy. Just won't work for them.

Look at the campaigns of Black candidates who have gone after something larger than a safe gerrymandered Congressional seat...what is their campaign focused around?
Reaching out to the ENTIRE community.

They have to, because they are Black. And, the ONLY way that, as a Black candidate, you will be able to WIN, is to appeal to a broad constituency. It's the ONLY way.

Barack Obama does it. (he won the Senate)
Harold Ford did it. (he lost the Senate)
Deval Patrick did it. (he won)
Adrian Fenty did it. (he won)
Douglas Wilder did it.(he won)
Tom Bradley did it. (he lost)
David Dinkins did it. (he won)
Harvey Gantt did it (he lost)
Roland Burris (Illinois) and Carl McCall (New York) did it. (both lost)
In the midst of one of the most racially polarizing campaigns in the history of this country, Harold Washington did it.

The MINUTE Barack Obama turns into that 'attack dog' that the Progressives are clamoring for, what will happen?

He will become THE ANGRY BLACK MAN.

He knows it.

I know it.

And, then, THERE will be ANOTHER excuse as to why they can't vote for Obama.

Obama understands that and is NOT going to fall into THAT trap.

That mode of campaign doesn't work with Black candidates. It's not an option for a Black candidate - not if they want to WIN. And make no mistake, Barack is running to WIN.

There you go, Krugman.

Anyway, my predictions for today: Edwards and Romney take Iowa. Let's see what happens.

A Pertinent Set Of Questions

From our favorite Pakistan political commentary blog:
Clearly, Musharraf is most moved by the deterioration of law and order, which he sees ultimately as an attack on his power. The murder of a two-time prime minister near the seat of the army, in his view, is now a peripheral matter. If it was truly primary, he would announce an independent commission, formed in concert with the opposition, to supervise the investigation.

Moreover, if he truly believes that Baitullah Mehsud is responsible for the murder of a former Pakistani prime minister, shouldn’t he have announced that the army would make a renewed, aggressive attempt to apprehend Mehsud, try him before a court of law, and – if convicted – execute him? Is not the murder of a former prime minister, in effect, an act of treason?

Wednesday, January 02, 2008

On Technology In Cricket

I need a break from Pakistani politics for a day. I will thus choose to ignore the seductive powers of commenting on Bilawal (Bhutto) Zardari's love for Buffy The Goddamn Vampire Slayer, and instead focus on another burning issue: umpires in cricket and how much they suck.

For those unaware, India got screwed today. I didn't watch it, but from all accounts, they had Ponting twice (before he got out) and Symonds thrice. Of course, the latter helped them recover from 130-6 to 370-7 and will resume on 137 tomorrow. It also appears that none of the decisions were marginal, with the commentators piling on Bucknor and Benson. Wasim wondered whether Bucknor can still see and hear, and Michael Slater said that "Ponting didn't nick it, he smashed it." Reaction from Indian bloggers/reporters saw predictable hand-wringing - Prem Panicker in particular was worth the read.
_____________________________________________________________________________________

It is my contention that cricket needs to employ the use of more technology in umpiring decisions. The standard of umpiring in the last five years has been abysmal, with only Taufel, and to a more limited extent Aleem Dar being serviceable (though Taufel is more than "serviceable" - he's simply the best umpire I've ever seen, by a long way). From Fat Fuck Hair to the two blind West Indians (Billy and Steve), from nutty Bowden to crackpot Rudy, there have been too many terrible "mistakes" lately. I use inverted commas because the nature of these errors defies the belief that they were unwitting. Sometimes you just need to see which official is umpiring which team to know how the result will pan out. If Fat Fuck Hair is umpiring a Pakistan game, forget about it. Dani will keep screaming but he won't get an LBW. Opposition batsmen will knock the cover off the ball but will stand their ground and have their stance vindicated. Similarly, if Bucknor is officiating an India game, you know you're going to see at least three howlers, with either Tendulkar, Dravid or Ganguly especially prone to a "misjudgment". The opposite - but equally dangerous - phenomenon takes place when Bowden umpires an Australia match. He will fold under the pressure they so expertly exert, and the opposition - already under pressure from playing an awesome team - will simply collapse. It's hard enough beating Australia with 11 batsmen, but with Bowden, you only have the services of six or seven. Warne played that man like he would a nurse with text messages.

Why don't we use more technology in cricket? It's a fairly straightforward question, but it elicits some fairly retarded answers. A popular one is "it will take time out of the game". Time out of the game? The purest form of the sport lasts 35 hours, for God's sake. Surely it would be worth the extra 15 seconds it would take to reach the correct decision? Most incorrect decisions can be shown to be so before the bowler is even back to his mark, with up to 30-60 seconds between deliveries - even for spinners. And if officials are really worried about "time out of the game," they would do well to direct their ire elsewhere, such as the endless non-official drinks breaks (even when the weather is fine), lengthy chats between captains and bowlers, batsmen spending inordinate amounts of time gardening the pitch, and so on.

What are some of the other reasons we don't see greater technology in cricket? We're told it's a game, and part of the charm is the human element and the mistakes all of us make. That may be true, but it's a misplaced opinion. The charm of cricket lies in the mistakes batsmen, bowlers, and fielders make, not the ones the umpires make. When Gibbs dropped Steve Waugh at that game in the 1999 World Cup, that was a "good" mistake because it was one made by one of the participants of the game. The umpires, on the other hand, are not participants. They are not in the game but above it, only overseeing matters and, at their best, never affecting the outcome.

Another reason for the unpopularity of technology, put forth by Ian Chappell if I recall correctly, is that sport is meant to imitate life, and life is never a completely smooth road. We are never dealt perfect hands, and how we deal with those hands reveals and builds character. Therefore, the reasoning goes, handling bad decisions by umpires is part and parcel of playing sport for a living, and one we should cherish. Despite my unending admiration and respect for Chappell, this is dumb. In real life, when we are dealt harsh judgments, we have recourse to appeals (well, in most countries anyway). You have lawyers and DNA evidence and juries and deliberation and whatnot. If you've been screwed, you have a chance to be unscrewed, so to speak. This is not the case in cricket where, as we've all been told since we were kids, the umpire's decision is final.
_____________________________________________________________________________________

All of these explanations miss the central point of sport, namely, to assess which of two teams or individuals is better. This is especially true at international level but also applies to backyard cricket. All of us amateurs may play cricket for "fun," but at the end of the day, we all want to win, because we think our team is better than the other one. I have never, ever, EVER gone in to any contest of any kind with a peer (my three year old niece does not count) not wanting to win. The point of a contest is to determine which of two teams is more adept at the skill in question, whether it's a Scrabble game with my fiancee or a World Cup final between Argentina and Brazil. Anything that interferes with that determination is clearly a detraction from the contest.

It is also important to emphasize that most people who favor greater use of technology in cricket aren't advocating anything truly revolutionary. I for one don't want to see Hawk-Eye make LBW decisions. Even though it has been used successfully in tennis, there is a crucial difference in the use of the Hawk-Eye in tennis and its prospective use in cricket. In tennis, Hawk-Eye shows where the ball went. In cricket, Hawk-Eye predicts where the ball is going. To me, that makes its use for LBWs a non-starter. I also don't want hot-spot or any other of these military infra-red technologies.

No, what I and many others including classy Duncan Fletcher propose is something much more limited. Namely, grant each side a finite number of appeals per innings (three or five or whatever). If a side doesn't agree with a decision, it can appeal it. The decision, whether it is a caught behind or LBW, can be overturned if and only if it is shown to be absolutely and positively incorrect within some agreed upon time frame (say a minute or 45 seconds). Such language can be written in the legislation to make the burden of proof weighty and make it rest on the shoulders of the appealing side. This will ensure that marginal decisions, even if incorrect, stand. Only the most egregious mistakes will be eradicated under this system, which is all we really want anyway. This system will also allay the fears of those who want umpires to have a role in the game. Under these rules, the umpires on the field will make a decision as they always have done, and will only be brought into question if they've fucked up majorly (which they should).
_____________________________________________________________________________________

There is most definitely a silver lining to India getting screwed today. No, this is not typical Pakistani schadenfreude at our neighbor's expense. On the contrary, I am extremely sympathetic because (a) they had a real chance to get back in the series when the Aussies were 130-6, and (b) I know exactly how they feel, with our tour to England in 2006 and Australia in 2004-05 especially marred by crappy umpiring.

No, my glee with India getting screwed today is the potential it holds for real and positive change. When teams like Pakistan bear the brunt of bad umpiring, it is written off as complaining by an inferior team that has no right to say anything about rules given how many times we break them (a fair point when you consider drugs, ball tampering, hitting spectators with bats, scuffing up pitches et al). On the other hand, India has real clout and usually gets what it wants when it comes to the ICC. Perhaps today's events will bring about an urgency within their administration to push for new legislation vis-a-vis technology in cricket. As Andrew Sullivan would say, know hope.
_____________________________________________________________________________________

I should note that I am somewhat sympathetic to umpires' predicament nowadays. Because of the two neutral umpires requirement for all tests, umpires end up traveling and working more than players. Almost all are significantly older than the players- with the exception of Taufel, which I don't think is a coincidence - and the fatigue must play havoc with their ability to concentrate for seven hours a day and make snap judgments.

This is why I am perplexed umpires don't want more technology used in the sport. I can understand their worries about eventually being phased out of the game, but they should rest assured that those worries are misplaced. After all, both American football and tennis employ technology quite a bit, and officials in those sports are still alive and kicking. At the end of the day, umpires should want to place a priority on getting decisions right, rather than fear being shown up by television. Being that insecure means they're probably ill-suited to the requirements of being an international umpire anyway, and should probably look for another job. If they want, I'm sure Darrell Hair can give them tips on seeking alternative forms of employment.

The Plight Of Grad Students

At Purdue, they're smelling cow shit for money. Hey man, I'd do it.

A Milestone

Oil hits a hundred bucks a barrel. Remember, kids: global warming is a hoax.

Well, At Least He Has One Thing Going For Him

My collective opinion on women has fallen several notches after reading this.
Bilawal Bhutto, thrust into the political spotlight by the assassination of his mother in Pakistan, can count on support from at least one source -- female Facebook fans who describe him as "hot".

"Oh My God he's cute," said one contributor to "Let's not assassinate Bilawal Bhutto because he's hot, ok?," a new group on the social networking site after the 19-year-old was named last week to succeed his mother as leader of the Pakistan People's Party (PPP).

"Oh God, I totally agree. He's so sexy," added another member of the group, which so far had 48 members.

Tuesday, January 01, 2008

Happy New Year To All

Here are 13 lucky predictions for 2008. Readers are invited to submit their own in the comments section.

1. The PPP storms to an election victory, and Amin Fahim becomes Prime Minister. The PPP splits into two camps as a power tussle ensues between Fahim and Zardari. Bilawal wonders what the hell he's gotten himself into.

2. John McCain beats Hillary Clinton in a tight race to become U.S. President. Joe Lieberman is his veep. The Clintons put us all out of our misery and get a divorce.

3. The MQM and PPP split the city government in Karachi, leading to the only situation in the world where an impasse and chaos exist simultaneously.

4. Chicago stays cold. I bitch about it until 2009.

5. Australia continue to dominate, winning 16 of their 18 tests in the year, drawing with New Zealand once and losing to the Windies once. Ponting ends the year with 43 total test hundreds and ups his average to 61.

6. Phoenix beats San Antonio to reach the Finals after ugly injuries to Duncan and Bowen in a collision suffered in practice. Their joy is short-lived as they lose to Boston in the Finals in 5 games.

7. Man U win the Premiership. Real win the Champions League and La Liga. Barca sell Ronaldinho for 80 million to Chelsea, fire Rijkaard and hire Mourinho. I stop supporting Barca.

8. There is a massive breakdown in Pakistan-Afghanistan relations, as a surge in violence in the border areas, due primarily to a destabilized Pakistan government, forces Karzai and Musharraf on to the back foot.

9. Musharraf stays in power.

10. Paul Krugman and Bill Kristol have to be separated by Tom Friedman, as a tussle over who gets to the office water cooler faster quickly morphs into a fistfight. They're then given a talking to on coexistence by Nick Kristof. Maureen Dowd writes a hilarious-but-at-times-indecipherable column on the incident.

11. Younis becomes Pakistan captain, with Lawson fired as coach and Malik dropped as captain (and player) by April. Younis' form as a batsman suffers, leading to speculation of Misbah's ascension to the role.

12. China and Japan pull the global economy out of a mini-recession.

13. I continue to make retarded predictions that never come true. Our readers continue to point and laugh.

Sunday, December 30, 2007

More On Conspiracy Theories

I just want to piggyback off of NB's excellent post on conspiracy theories for a second. Many non-Pakistanis would gaze in wonderment at our dexterity in assigning blame based on outcomes. Almost always in Pakistani drawing rooms and lounges, one (evil) beneficiary of a certain action is identified and then made responsible for said action, despite absolutely no evidence for such an assertion. The lack of evidence is written off as the result of the nefarious designs of the extremely adroit conspirator ("you really think they would leave evidence?").

There are a couple of points to be made about this "logic". First, if it is taken to its logical conclusion, then we must blame (a) Iran and China for the Iraq war, (b) the U.S. for World War II, (c) Tim Duncan for the Shaq-Kobe feud, and (d) Subway for McDonald's. The fact that no evidence exists for Iran and China instigating the Iraq war, the Americans instigating World War II, Tim Duncan instigating the Shaq-Kobe feud, or Subway convincing McDonald's to use approximately 450 tons of fat in each burger only shows us how brilliant and conniving each of Iran, China, America, Tim Duncan and Subway really are.

The second point to be made is that even if you ignore the ridiculousness of the general "logic" outlined above, it still doesn't make sense in this particular case. As NB mentioned, there are no conceivable set of circumstances under which Musharraf would have benefited from BB's death. He already had what he wanted: the office of the Presidency secured, a pliant judiciary, a muzzled media, the continued support of the West in general and the U.S. in particular, and the participating of all the main parties in the general elections (the PML-N agreed to contest despite Nawaz Sharif not being allowed to run for God's sake). What else could he have possible wanted? And how might have those desires been furthered by murdering BB? To blame Musharraf for this, in my mind, is simply foolish.

Be that as it may, I am not prepared to completely eliminate the possibility of official/establishment involvement. A number of rogue elements within the ISI, in conjunction with some retired generals (ahem, Hameed Gul) and current politicians (*cough Ijaz-ul-Haq cough*) could have conceivably used some nutter to further their objectives by getting rid of BB. But - and this is crucial - the burden of evidence lies on the conspiracy theorists to show it isn't just some Baitullah Mehsud disciple carrying out orders, because that is the most obvious and natural explanation for this. I think we as a nation would do well to familiarize ourselves with the concept of Occam's razor.

All this said, I'm wondering if Pakistanis would have been so quick to blame Musharraf for BB's death if it had happened a year or two ago - before the firing of the Chief Justice (the first time), before the emergency, before the clampdown on the media, before May 12, and before the price of flour went through the roof. Clearly, it's not just about wild imaginations but popularity ratings as well. It is extremely difficult to imagine Musharraf being held culpable for this back when he enjoyed 60% approval ratings. In a perverse way, Musharraf deserves what he's getting here. If he hadn't made so many mistakes, he wouldn't be blamed for one he didn't make.

Bhutto's Assassins and Destructive Conspiracy Theories

New footage has appeared of Benazir Bhutto's shooter, alongside a man alleged to have been the suicide bomber. This seems to disprove the Government's account and the coroners report that she was killed after colliding with the sunroof lever due to the outward force of the blast. You can see the video from Dawn Television below:





That said, the specifics are immaterial. Whether she died by gunshot, or by the blast, the fact remains that she was standing outside the sunroof and that she was killed by her assassins. Whether her death was caused by gunshot, shrapnel, or the force of the explosion has no logical bearing upon the actual blameworthiness of the government. It neither assists Musharraf nor does it reflect worse upon him. The shrapnel/bullet/sunroof debate (started by the somewhat pointless Sherry Rehman) is therefore pointless, and is not an appropriate topic for public discussion, not least because it has zero bearing on any one parties culpability. It should be determined upon by the investigating authorities, regardless of their inevitable shortcomings.

Exhortations to dig up Benazir's body just a day after her burial to resolve such a ridiculous dispute are indicative of the madness that is now pervasive. The governments immediate declaration of willingness to accede to such demands is further indicative of their sheer desperation to acquit themselves of a charge that should never have been made against them in the first place.

Just to put this particular sub-debate in context, it has somehow become wound up with the broader conspiracy theory proposed by many that Musharraf actually orchestrated Benazir's death (rather than the softer version wherein he was simply negligent in permitting it). I have reproduced Robert Fisk's astoundingly daft version below:

"So let's run through this logic in the way that Inspector Ian Blair might have done in his policeman's notebook before he became the top cop in London.
Question: Who forced Benazir Bhutto to stay in London and tried to prevent her return to Pakistan?
Answer:General Musharraf.

Question: Who ordered the arrest of thousands of Benazir's supporters this month?
Answer: General Musharraf.

Question: Who placed Benazir under temporary house arrest this month?
Answer: General Musharraf.

Question: Who declared martial law this month?
Answer General Musharraf.

Question: who killed Benazir Bhutto?
Er. Yes. Well quite."
Just to clarify, Fisk thinks that the above Q & A speaks for itself in terms of Musharraf's apparently obvious culpability. Fisk's regrettably simplistic efforts notwithstanding, it is close to impossible to actually reason out a comprehensive scenario where it was in Musharraf's interest to kill Benazir. A simple glance at the state the Country is in today should establish that. Secondly and more importantly, even if one outcome did benefit a party it may legitmatley raises a suspicion, but it should not result in an irrefutable charge being made against that party, which is essentially what a conspiracy theory does. A paucity of information should result in a simple "I don't know" rather than a convoluted conspiracy theory.

That said, it should be noted that there is some information in the current instance. This conspiracy theory exists notwithstanding an apparent initial admission by Al-Qaeda, an alleged confession tape by Baitullah Mehsud, and a belatedly thin denial by the latter which incredibly states that "it is against tribal tradition and custom to attack a woman". Baitullah Mehsud apparently lives in an alternate dimension where his brain has been replaced by a walnut, where honor killings don't take place and where suicide bombs have somehow always been intelligent enough to focus their explosive force exclusively upon men and not women. That is not to suggest that Baitullah Mehsud is actually guilty or that the government was correct in identifying him, but rather that his explanation is just about as implausible as they come.

I would submit that the creation and proliferation of conspiracy theories following Benazir's assassination is extremely damaging and detrimental to Pakistan for two reasons:

1) Armchair conspiracy theories and baseless punditry place the burden of proof upon the government to somehow prove their innocence in the matter. Rather than rupturing further, Pakistan's society and state should be galvanizing in outrage against religiously bigoted militancy or at the very least against the use of such horrific violence against our own people. Conspiracy theories however misdirect public anger, with the kind of catastrophic effects were now witnessing across Sindh. The Jihadis (who are a real problem regardless of their culpability for this crime) are effectively rewarded through the instigation of a conflict between their biggest opponents, namely the PPP and the Army, or Musharraf and the PPP (or Punjab and Sindh, depending on which fault line you want to use as perspective). If they are responsible, it's two birds with one blast, and plenty of innocent Pakistanis to follow.

2) Conspiracy theories are not premised upon evidence but rather the lack thereof. The absence of evidence to prove the 'official' hypothesis somehow 'proves' the idiotic conspiratorial hypothesis, i.e "there's no evidence, therefore there must be a cover up". Contending that conjecture stands proven because of the absence of evidence is circular and stupid. We should only be drawing conclusions when real proof, i.e. a motive plus incriminating evidence, is established.

By reversing the burden of proof, conspiracy theories create new issues and new sub-disputes which cannot essentially be resolved (e.g. the pointless sunroof v bullet dispute although that can be resolved, albeit only by exhuming the body). In the future, this debate will stalemate and become knotted, locking innocent parties in a poisonous blame game and preventing the country from moving on and forward. Moreover, the entrenchment of such conspiracy theories prevents people from obtaining closure in the future and prolongs their grief.

Why then do Pakistanis love to subscribe to such investigative jiggery pokery? Well, there has traditionally been a vacuum of credible information in Pakistan. Moreover, the government has historically been positively in-credible and understandably, conspiracy theories tend to flourish in such an environment. Less understandably, that proclivity is further assisted by our individual penchants for gossip, our desire for self-importance and our unflagging ability to draw macro conclusions from bizzare & unreliable anecdotal information received from an uncle.

Additionally, we are extremely willing to believe whatever we like about people we don't like. Consequently, many Pakistanis simply don't like to make well reasoned and slightly obvious conclusions where it's entirely more gratifying to blame people we already hate. Which is why Musharraf somehow orchestrated the Lal Masjid uprising and Benazir's assassination, and which is why the Jews are somehow responsible for 9/11 (and Benazir's assassination, because those we hate love each other obviously).

So by that logic, I hate Atif Aslam, he is therefore responsible for pretty much everything bad because when people are sad they buy his crappy power ballads, and unless he can prove that he didn't secretly orchestrate everything by instructing someone who instructed someone else to instruct someone else to carry out something which caused everything to get messed up, he's clearly guilty.

Chalo. Now lets go burn some banks.

Friday, December 28, 2007

Interior Ministry: BB Didn't Die From Bullet Wound

I just saw a spokesperson from the Ministry of Interior claiming that Benazir didn't die as a result of a gunshot but from hitting her head against the sun-roof lever in her car. The government is also stating it has strong proof of al-Qaeda's involvement in the assassination. In other news, the Army has moved into Sindh and Benazir was buried after Friday prayers today amidst scenes of anguish and despair.

In Rs.5 news, I will be traveling over the next 24 hours or so. I am actually headed out of the country. No, I'm not running away - though I will concede the timing is extraordinarily convenient...or extraordinarily inconvenient, depending on how you look at it. I'm actually going back to school. Luckily for our readers, AKS should be returning from his vacation tomorrow, refreshed and (hopefully) ready to blog - internet connection and AKS' incredible laziness notwithstanding.

Breaking News: Rangers Given Shoot-At-Sight Orders

DawnNews is reporting that Rangers (a paramilitary organization) have been given shoot-at-sight orders against arsonists in Sindh.

UPDATE at 08:40 GMT: There are numerous reports of violence and rioting taking place all over the country in towns and cities alike. Sindh's situation is deteriorating more rapidly than other areas, and the Rangers have been deployed in Thatta (a rural town in Sindh). Mobs have generally taken to damaging and burning motor vehicles (buses, vans, cars, motorbikes) and offices of the PML-Q and the MQM around the country. A news item on Aaj showed how the country has come to a complete standstill: businesses and offices are shuttered up, schools and colleges shut, the Karachi stock exchange closed, and all transport off the road. I also saw a ticker-tape item on DawnNews (whose coverage, by the way, has been superb) saying that three PPP workers have been shot dead by the police. Regardless of how disorderly PPP supporters might be at this point, is it really a good idea for the police to be killing PPPers the day after their leader was assassinated?

UPDATE at 08:48 GMT: In election news, caretaker Prime Minister Soomro has said that elections will be held on time. As many will know, Nawaz Sharif's PML-N decided to boycott the elections last night. The MQM, meanwhile, has asked for the elections to be postponed.

The Mourning After

The country is in a three day mourning period with flags at half-mast and the roads completely empty. If you're from Karachi, you simply cannot recognize the lack of traffic - it's like that scene in Vanilla Sky when Tom Cruise ends up in Times Square with no soul in sight. There have been a number of flashes of protest/anger/rioting/tire-burning/vandalism though.

The picture of Benazir's killing is pretty clear. Benazir was in the back of a four-wheeler and stood up on the seat to wave at supporters through the sun-roof as she was leaving Liaquat Bagh. She was shot in the neck and chest, forcing her to get back in the car where she put her head into someone else's lap, bleeding profusely. As the car tried to make an escape from the premises a few seconds later, a suicide bomber with up to 4kg (about 9 pounds) of explosives blew himself up. Benazir died of her injuries on the way to hospital and will be buried later today in her hometown of Larkana in interior Sindh.

The blame game has already begun, with many questioning Benazir's security arrangements. It's unclear to me what role greater security could have played given that Benazir was basically a sitting duck: standing on a seat of a car, waving through the sun-roof, in a slow-moving vehicle through throngs of supporters in a constrained space - I mean, that's an assassin's dream, isn't it? Of course, I am not ruling out the culpability of the establishment or government - I am only ruling out the potential of greater security to have obviated the assassination.

It's also worth mentioning that I have about as much confidence in a real and thorough investigation as I do in Imran Farhat's catching ability (i.e. not very much). First of all, television pictures yesterday showed the police using those really powerful water pipes to clean the area of all the blood and body parts. I don't know about their intentions, but they definitely guaranteed the complete absence of any forensic evidence. Second, it is now been twenty years since that Zia fellow suddenly had his plane explode in thin air, and no one - I mean no one - has any idea of what the hell happened. If a sitting President - and Army General - can have his plane explode without any explanation, what chance does a mere opposition leader have? I'll be willing to wager that we will never know what happened on December 27, 2007, notwithstanding al-Qaeda's claims.

Thursday, December 27, 2007

What Benazir's Assassination Means

To understand why Benazir Bhutto’s death is so important – not just tragic, but of grave consequence – you must first ask yourself the question: which fissures in society are the most highly politicized? In Pakistan the answers are: religion and ethnicity. Class is not much of an issue in Pakistani politics – most serious left of center parties as well any semblance of a Marxist-Lite movement were wiped out by the establishment by the 1970s. Only the PPP is a truly viable left of center party today, and it isn’t significantly left of center either. No party is said to cater exclusively or even primarily the poor and most if not all parties are run be elites.

No, in Pakistan the true lightning rods have been ethnicity (historically) and religion (recently). These issues have driven the agenda in the political landscape since the country’s inception and continue to do so today. Ethnic politics manifests itself in center-provincial and provincial-provincial relations because most of Pakistan’s ethnicities are neatly encapsulated by separate provinces (the Bengalis lived in East Pakistan until 1971, the Pukhtoons live in NWFP, the Balochis in Balochistan, the Punjabis in Punjab, and the Sindhis and Mohajirs share Sindh), with only the megacities – Islamabad/Rawalpindi, Lahore, and Karachi – displaying any degree of metropolitan-ness. The issues which are usually used to assert positions in these battles are things like language policy, water issues, military recruitment, and taxes and spending. Religious politics, meanwhile, have become more overt in the last twenty years. It’s not just NY Times-front-page-type stuff like terrorism or militancy where religious politics plays itself out but also on issues such as rape laws and passports. Both issues have the power to inflame passions and result in significant violence – though only ethnic issues have the potential to result in widespread violence.

_____________________________________________________________________________________

Already two explanations are being forwarded insofar as the culprits of the assassination are concerned. The first is that the Taliban or some other Islamic militant organization targeted Benazir for her promising to tackle extremism and militancy. They saw her as a threat and killed her just like they tried to kill Musharraf or Shaukat Aziz or Sherpao. The second explanation is more of a conspiracy theory. It says that our military agencies in consort with the senior leadership of the PML-Q took Benazir out because she was a threat to their hold on power. They point to the fact that another strong party – the PML-N – was targeted earlier in the day. They also point, somewhat more credibly, to Benazir’s letter to Musharraf before she returned to Pakistan where she pointed out some names that might wish her harm. Included in those names was Ijaz Shah, the head honcho of one of Pakistan’s intelligence agencies, and, according to rumors, the Chaudhries of Gujarat: Pervez Elahi and Chaudhry Shujaat.

The second explanation holds significantly more potential for violence. The Chaudhries are from Punjab and have essentially ruled the province these last five years. The Pakistan military and intelligence agencies are also seen to be Punjabi entities. The Bhutto family, on the other hand, is about as Sindhi as Sindhi can get. The point to note is that it doesn’t even matter if the Punjabi-establishment explanation is true. What matters is if people believe it is true. And by people, I mean really pissed off PPP workers.

As I type this, reports of violence in the urban areas of Sindh are coming through on television. In Karachi, riots and tire-burning started almost immediately after news of Benazir’s death was confirmed. A hospital was set on fire and a jail (Gulistan-e-Jauhar for the Karachiites out there) was attacked. Five people have been killed so far in firing in the city. This much, I think, was expected. The danger, of course, is that, in the Sindhi PPP worker’s mind, this is about Sindh and Punjab, and that today’s almost spontaneous violence becomes tomorrow’s more calculated and narrowly aimed. In other words, if the court of public opinion privileges the second explanation – the Punjabi establishment one – over the first – the Taliban/militant one – then we could be on the cusp on the breakout of Pakistan’s first brush with mass, widespread violence since 1971.

_____________________________________________________________________________________

There is a very good reason a number of analysts on television have already shone a light on calming Sindhi sentiments. There is a very good reason Nawaz Sharif, a Punjabi leader of a large national but largely Punjabi party for non-Pakistani readers, said in his press conference a little over a half hour ago that “in their time of grief, I want Sindh to know that the PML-N is with them…that Nawaz Sharif is with them.” Center-province relations have been fraught at the best of times but this type of incident has Archduke Ferdinand-type power. Almost everyone – student organizations, political parties, religious organizations – is armed at the neighborhood or district level, and those that are not armed can become so fairly quickly (in Pakistan, only hash is as easy to procure as a weapon). It does not take a great deal of imagination to picture a Pakistan where a widespread conflict erupts between Punjabis and Sindhis, especially if the Army becomes involved in trying to maintain order (which it most likely will). In short, Newsweek’s infamous cover proclaiming Pakistan the most dangerous country in the world could conceivably become a reality. A large ethnic conflict, coupled with militant violence in the NWFP and a nationalist movement in Balochistan (already happening), in addition to rampant inflation and socioeconomic pressures (already happening) in an unstable country with an unstable leader and, oh yeah, nuclear weapons? Yup, I think that would about cover it.

Even if that worst-cast scenario does not materialize, there is bound to be certain level of street violence in the coming days. Riots and strikes should be the norm and I anticipate extremely high levels of tension. I think we can also safely say goodbye to the prospect of elections in January. The idea of elections does not just seem implausible to me at this point but also somewhat inappropriate. At the very least they should be postponed four weeks to give everyone time to grieve (and take a deep breath). What sort of elections would we see under the current circumstances anyway?

_____________________________________________________________________________________

Readers, if you are not in Pakistan, there is simply no way I can convey the sense of shock pervasive here. It gets more surreal hour by hour. A significant part of me simply cannot believe that she is dead. Over the last two years or so, I grew to admire and respect Benazir, despite her many faults. As regulars will know, I loudly supported her and her party. But today cannot be about politics. Even those who hated Benazir, and hated her positions, cannot be anything but immensely grieved and deeply disturbed by today’s events. It is, without a doubt, one of the saddest days in Pakistan’s history and a true national tragedy. Our thoughts are with her family, and may her soul rest in peace.

Breaking News: Benazir Bhutto Killed In Suicide Attack

If you're counting, that's three (maybe four) Bhuttos that have met politically motivated deaths. I will be blogging updates as I watch Aaj, Geo and ARY.

What we know so far is that Benazir was one of the victims of a suicide blast outside Liaqat Bagh (a park named after Pakistan's first Prime Minister, also assassinated) in Rawalpindi as she was leaving a political rally. Right now, the news channels keep replaying the last few scenes from BB's life, as she descends from the podium from which she delivered her speech into her bulletproof four-wheeler. More to follow.

UPDATE at 13:58 GMT: Reports are streaming in that shopkeepers in the urban areas of Sindh, the PPP's primary stronghold, are closing down their businesses. In Larkana, people have come out on to the streets and burned tires. In Karachi and Hyderabad, people have come out on the street. I myself saw an increased security presence in Karachi a few minutes after her death was confirmed, including a helicopter and some police cars and checkpoints. DawnNews is reporting that the government is asking people to stay indoors.

UPDATE at 14:07 GMT: Aaj just reported that a bullet was also found in her neck. So much for the bulletproof vehicle.

UPDATE at 14:19 GMT: A report that the death toll is up to 25 and that Sherry Rehman and Naheed Malik are among the injured. DawnNews reports that a motorcyclist apparently rammed into her vehicle and blew himself up. I really can't describe the state of shock pervasive here, both among people calling our house and the journalists on TV.

UPDATE at 14:33 GMT: BBC is reporting that as Benazir rose to wave from her car to supporters (presumably through a sun-roof) when she was leaving the scenes, she was shot three times in the neck and head before a suicide bomber blew himself up. She died on the way to the hospital.

UPDATE at 14:37 GMT: Aaj is reporting rioting and violence in the two strongest PPP areas in Karachi: Lyari and Malir.

UPDATE at 14:56 GMT: Jamaat-e-Islami shows its class. Some senior JI official (Munawar Hassan) started railing against Musharraf, dictatorship and 8-tear tenures while a DawnNews anchor tried in vain to get him to talk about BB. Mullahs never disappoint.

UPDATE at 15:03 GMT: After chairing a high level cabinet meeting, President Musharraf
on state television appealed for calm and restraint in the nation so that the "evil designs of the terrorists" could be defeated.

UPDATE at 15:28 GMT: Reaction has streamed in from all over. President Bush called the attack cowardly and said the U.S. stood by Pakistan in its fight against extremism and terror. The British Prime Minister said it was a sad day for democracy and a tragic day for Pakistan. Condolences have flown in from all over the world, including India and France, as well as condemnation of the attack.

UPDATE at 20:35 GMT: Aaj is reporting violence in Karachi has simmered down, though that may have less to do with tempers calming and more to do with the fact that even rioters need to sleep (it's half past one in the morning here). I have also heard that the Army has been readied in Sindh to move in, though I haven't heard anything official about martial law or anything of the sort. The movements and words of various people such as Musharraf, Asif Zardari, Nawaz Sharif, and the Chaudhries will be crucial tomorrow.

Wednesday, December 26, 2007

Quote Of The Day

The difference between Madrid and Barcelona is the difference between an antelope and a lion. And I don't remember a single documentary where the antelope wins.

Marca's Roberto Palomar. Having watched El Clasico between Barcelona and Madrid on Sunday, I'm inclined to agree with him. Not the whole antelope-and-lion bit, but the not-winning bit. Barca are now seven points behind a very solid looking Madrid, still yet to play at the Bernabeu. They put in a pitiful performance on Sunday night, they really did. Iniesta was the only bright spot - other than that, too many people had too quiet games: Eto'o, Deco, Xavi to name just three.

And then there's Ronaldinho. I think it's become clear that him and Barca must part ways. I say this with a somewhat-but-not-completely heavy heart. Most will understand by ambivalence. On the one hand, he is still young, and there is the feeling that the right manager, someone who would light a fire under his ass, could get him nearing the heights of his 2004-2006 form, still fresh in the minds of Barca fans. On the other hand, however, he looks increasingly overweight and not committed enough (hmm, I haven't typed those words on this blog with respect to anyone else, have I?), and I'm not sure I would want someone like that on my team, irrespective of the manager.

I don't think anything will happen in January, even if Milan or Chelsea (the two most interested suitors) come in with an outlandish offer. I think the club will give Rijkaard a chance to steady the ship, to see if he can get this La Liga campaign kick-started after the new year and still put in a solid performance in Europe. I also think that after his play against Real, nobody will complain if Ronaldinho is on the bench the rest of the year, unless his training and practicing habits change. This will allow Rijkaard to play the team he wants, and see how good that team can be. A Barca with Ronaldinho out, Messi fit and Eto'o and Yaya Toure back from the African Nations Cup will still be a massive contender in Europe, though as I said earlier, I think the 1-0 loss to Madrid at home has effectively ended the La Liga campaign. At the end of the season, the club will see where it's at and will in all likelihood let Rijkaard walk and sell Ronaldinho for an exorbitantly overpriced fee.

By the way, just a word about Madrid: they are an excellent team. They are very much for real, and they along with Man United are my new favorites for the Champions League (with Arsenal, Barca and Inter my second tier candidates). They are very different from years past and have a very steely look to them both in the middle of the park and up front. Not that Real ever really fly under the radar, but I feel people have sort of forgotten about them this season, and I have no idea why. They never really gave Barca a chance on Sunday and thoroughly outclassed them. It didn't even look particularly competitive, which was the worrying thing for me personally.

Please come back, Messi.

Tuesday, December 18, 2007

"Can You Change It Please?" (Video Of The Day)

Owing to his fondness for diving, his meterosexual eye-brows, and his very real and undeniable talent, Cristiano Ronaldo is one of the most reviled players in the world. This video is a gift to those who indulge in said reviling.

Two Steps, One Objective

The following ad was placed in yesterday's Dawn [and I'm sure various other newspapers]. I reproduce it here for the viewing pleasure of those unfortunate enough not to be in Pakistan.


Saturday, December 15, 2007

Of Manifestos, Alliteration, And Acronyms

So party manifestos have been all the rage in the last couple of days. First, Benazir's PPP came out with their 5 E's manifesto, aimed at employment, education, energy, environment and equality. Not to be outdone in the alliteration sweepstakes, the PML-Q responded with their 5 D's manifesto which entailed democracy, development, devolution, diversity and defence. Nawaz Sharif and the PML-N decided to blaze their own trail, leaving the alliterations in their dust and instead turning to acronyms that spell real words. Check out what they came up with:

Restoration of the judiciary, democracy and 1973 constitution
Elimination of military's rule in politics
Security of life and property of the people
Tolerant and pluralistic society
Overall national reconciliation and institutional development
Relief for the poor through poverty alleviation
Employment, education, and health facilities for the citizens

RESTORE. For some reason, I couldn't stop laughing when I read this one. Did someone forget to tell good old Sharif bhai that in acronyms, you can't have each letter representing an entire goddamn sentence? Unbelievable.

For my mind, these manifestos are Royally and Excruciatingly Terrible Attempts at Replacing Dictatorship with Everlasting Democracy, or RETARDED.

Friday, December 14, 2007

Quotes Of The Day (Nutty Pervez Edition)

You know you're guaranteed some doozies when the Washington Post has a 5 page interview with Pervez Musharraf. What follow are the highlights of a truly remarkable sit-down.

Q. Will the judges be restored to their prior positions?

A. No, not at all. What judges? Why should they be restored? New judges are there. They will never be restored.

Q. People in the West will have a hard time understanding that.

A. Let them not understand. They should come to Pakistan and understand Pakistan.


And

Q. Then why are you now clamping down on the media? You seem far more angry now than ever before.

A. I think you are right. [Laughs] Why don't you understand? Am I a madman? Have I suddenly changed? Am I a Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde?


And

Q. But didn't you promise the U.S. last summer that you'd lift the ban on that [a third term for Prime Ministers]?

A. No, I haven't given any such promises. We did talk about it, but there were many things that we talked about which have been violated . . .

Q. And you feel you could work with her [Benazir Bhutto]?

A. I think so. I am not such an unpleasant person.

The Fallacious Logic Of Boycotting Elections

So my first discussion on politics took place about a minute and a half after I sat in the car on the way home from the airport a couple of days ago. My dad and I were talking about the forthcoming elections and the purpose served in boycotting them. My dad was adamant that no party should take part in the January elections, and that the proud lawyers movement had been sold down the drain by the power-hungry and unprincipled political parties.

This view is completely wrong-headed. First of all, it is not the political parties' job to represent the legal community's interests. If a political party feels it to be a wise and sound electoral strategy to support protesting lawyers, then it's all well and good. But political parties do not owe the lawyers' movement anything - anything at all - and if it is the case that certain parties are participating in elections, it does not mean those parties are somehow less "moral" or "principled" than those boycotting elections. It is merely the case that the former have calculated their interests differently than the latter. I am always very suspicious when people use words like "morals" and "principles" in the study of politics. I am especially suspicious of the employment of any framework which results in Imran Khan and Qazi Hussain Ahmed being cast as "moral" and "principled".

Moreover, participating in elections in and of itself does not confer legitimacy on them. To the contrary, it is only when one participates in elections that one has the right to shine light on their inherent flaws and illegitimacy. For instance, if the PML-N did not choose to participate in the elections, and the PML-Q cruised to victory in Punjab, then Nawaz Sharif could not have said a word about the rigging of elections (this idea brackets pre-poll irregularities such as differences in ability to organize rallies/advertising space on television/etc). Anything Sharif said could have been countered by the Chaudhries with, "Well, how do you know they were rigged? You didn't even fight the elections. Maybe we won a landslide victory because our main competitor (i.e. you) were not contesting them."

On the other hand, let's say the PML-Q wins 60 percent of the districts and seats in Punjab with Nawaz Sharif's PML participating. In that case, everyone will know something fishy happened. Actually, everyone knows something fishy is going to happen in these elections anyway, but at least the opposition parties will have a leg to stand on when the fishiness does finally ensue. Nawaz Sharif could say: "Look, the whole world knows your party is unpopular. The whole world also knows I am held in great esteem by many Punjabi voters. How the hell, then, did this come to pass?"

Don't underestimate the power of the crankiness of Benazir Bhutto and Nawaz Sharif post-elections. Having been pushed on to Musharraf by two of Pakistan's three most important foreign allies (the U.S. and Saudi Arabia respectively; by the way, who's China's candidate?), their satisfaction with the status quo post-elections will be important to power brokers abroad and, consequently, at home. Is this a perfect deterrent to unfair elections? No, of course not - it is more than likely that these elections will be grossly unfair. The question to ask, however, is not "Is participating in elections going to make them fair?" [no] but "Is participating in elections better than boycotting elections in terms of our ability to cry foul and declare them invalid and unfair after the fact?" [yes].

I am really open to the idea that contesting elections somehow grants them legitimacy. I don't believe it for a second but honestly, I'd love to hear a convincing explanation of the logic behind it. The prevailing conventional wisdom seems to be that once you agree to contest elections under a particular facade, you signal to the world that you find that facade acceptable. But that's a ridiculous notion, at least to me. The world will only believe your protestations against a facade once you've lived under it. This is why it is a good thing that Pakistan's two biggest parties, the PPP and the PML-N, have agreed to contest the forthcoming elections. Even under the most mangled of political circumstances, Pakistan is infinitely better off with the PPP and the PML-N fighting the system from within than without.

There seems to be an inverse relationship between one's strength of condemnation of Sharif's and Bhutto's moves to fight these elections and one's importance in Pakistan politics. In other words, it is incredibly easy, even beneficial, to cast BB and NS as villainous heathens bent on power and power alone if you're a small and insignificant party. It gets your name in the paper and gives you a visibility that you lacked before. Think Imran Khan and his one-seat party. Think Mahmood Khan Achakzai and the fact that you'd never even heard of his name until this blog post. Think Qazi Hussain and the JI, likely to be squeezed between the PPP, MQM and PML-Q like never before in Karachi and between the JUI (contesting elections, remember) and other smaller parties in NWFP (where it has never traditionally been a strong vote-getter). The only exceptions to this rule are the Aitzaz Ahsans of the world, but even in that case it is the exception that proves the rule. First, Aitzaz Ahsan is inexorably tied to the lawyers movement. His threshold for participating in elections will obviously be higher given his association with a movement that is unidirectional in nature: all the lawyers want is the exit of Musharraf and the return to the pre-November 3 judiciary. Second, even given these constraints, Aitzaz Ahsan was still willing to contest the elections provided BB budged a little on her post-election plans. Only when she told him to bugger off (itself a bit of a mystery to me - why doesn't BB see the favorable effects of AA's presence and think only in terms of her ego?) did AA decide that he wants no part of these elections.

Before I'm accused of betraying the revolution, please allow me to say what I'm not saying. I'm not saying any of Musharraf's and the Q League's shenanigans before these elections are acceptable. Furthermore, I'm not saying that contesting these elections guarantees, or even makes more likely, their fairness. What I am saying is that one's word against these elections is made significantly stronger and more reliable if one actually contested them. Now, if only my dad would believe me.

Update: A Poli Sci grad student at Columbia writes about a couple of themes touched upon in my post.